Call to Request a Free Consultation | Nou pale kreyòl
Government Argues it Can Freeze All Assets for Medicare Fraud One of Florida's Most Reputable Defense Law Firms

Government Argues It Can Freeze All Assets for Medicare Fraud

U.S. Supreme Court considers freezing of assets in Medicare fraud case.

The prospect of a federal investigation for Medicare fraud is terrifying. The prosecutorial powers of the federal government are vast, and prosecutors in Southern Florida and across the nation are under pressure to aggressively root out fraud and abuse related to federal programs. This means that they employ many tools to ascertain what appears to be fraud and then use that immense power to extract plea agreements.

The recent charges filed against numerous persons in South Florida this summer demonstrate how aggressive the U.S. Attorney's Office and other federal law enforcement agencies will be in pursuing Medicare fraud. The charges were filed against 73 individuals as part of a nationwide "takedown" involving 243 individuals in 17 cities. This massive operation was executed by the Medicare Fraud Strike Force.

Largest Medicare Fraud Takedown in Justice Department history

The Attorney General noted that, "This action represents the largest criminal healthcare fraud takedown in the history of the Department of Justice, and it adds to an already remarkable record of enforcement." They charged individuals involved at all levels of the healthcare industry.

The danger with transactions involving Medicare is that they are complex and many of the billing rules are very technical, meaning mistakes that may have been inadvertent may nonetheless appear to federal investigators as part of a pattern and practice of billing abuse and lead to federal charges of Medicare fraud.

For healthcare providers, doctors and pharmacists, the risk is that some action will trigger an interest and perhaps an investigation into your billing practices. This can mean that any unusual activity, odd billing patterns, mistakes or other issues with your billing can come under scrutiny.

Could they seize your assets?

In a related issue, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments on a case involving a woman who had been charged with Medicare fraud. Her home healthcare agency was charged with billing fraud, alleging that she billed for services that were not provided.

The government froze all of her assets, including those not related to her alleged fraud. Her attorney argued that freezing all assets deprived her of her Sixth Amendment right to counsel, as she could not afford to hire an attorney.

The Court, however, was skeptical of those arguments, with Justice Alito pointing out the fact that "money is fungible." They seemed worried at how to draw the line between tainted and untainted assets. On the other hand, Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kennedy noted that the government's argument could be applied to virtually every law, making it very difficult for many defendants to obtain counsel in a criminal prosecution.

Given the divided nature of questions expressed by the Supreme Court Justices, it is difficult to predict how the Court may rule in the future. The troubling growth in the use of civil forfeiture by law enforcement and concerns over the abuse of that practice could lead the Court to attempt to prevent overreaching and abusive forfeitures by the government.

No matter how the Court rules in this matter, if you are under investigation for any issues related to Medicare fraud, you need to obtain representation by an attorney familiar with these types of fraud, as the consequences of a federal civil or criminal action can be devastating.

Dedicated to Excellence

Read Our Client Reviews
  • Ted, Former Client

    Throughout the entire nightmare, Mr. Horwitz was by my side all the way. I could not have been better represented. Once indicted, I could not have had a better outcome.

  • Anonymous

    Mr. Citro knows the ins-and-outs of how the Government operates and works their cases.

  • Roshelle P., Former Client

    I know he fought for me and that's the best feeling you could ever have when you find yourself in the middle of a nightmare. I would highly recommend this law firm for anyone needing someone to fight for them!

  • Rob, Former Client

    The attention to detail and professional approach to my situation was extraordinary. Attorney Mark Horwitz made me feel like my case was important to him and that he and his staff cared about the outcome.

  • Daniel, Former Client

    Competent and thorough legal counsel!

  • John, Former Client

    Couldn’t have asked for a better outcome!

  • Nalita, Former Client

    I greatly appreciate the time and diligence that they spent on my case.

  • Cary

    This is the Attorney I highly recommend!

  • Randy P., Former Client

    I felt strong and confident that no other attorney team could have represented me better.

  • Anonymous, Former Client

    I received good quality legal services from an experienced and well respected lawyer.

The Edge You Need

6 Reasons to Hire Us
  • Former Federal Prosecutors
  • Board Certified with The Florida Bar & the National Board of Trial Advocacy
  • Personalized Client Service & Aggressive Legal Advocacy
  • Published Speakers/Authors & an Authority on Federal Matters
  • Regularly Featured in the News & Media
  • Highly Regarded by Peers, Prosecutors & Judges

Let's Discuss Your Case

Request a Free Consultation
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.